Discussion about this post

User's avatar
MartyB's avatar

Yeah, I wondered after I made my comment, if the the “recontextualized” referred to your point about the audience for Jesus’ comments. Thanks for clarity.

My thought was that this film adds context that I’m not sure has been filmed and may even be overlooked in regular reading or sermons on this event.

As far as the differences between Matthews and Marks accounts (I.e. Mark leaves out info Matthew includes) I don’t have anything specific to add other than the standard “each author edited differently because the may have had specific points they were making”.

Expand full comment
MartyB's avatar

I find your word “recontextulized” interesting.

Some might say the series is “contextualizing” the scene - adding context that has often been missing.

AIUI, it is believed that the temple of Pan in Caesarea Philipi carved in solid rock was considered a gateway to the underworld in pagan theology at the time.

So when Jesus referenced “Upon this rock I will build my church” and “the gates of hell/hades” he could have been alluding to something well known to his disciples at the time, related to the location they were near.

Personally I have read this passage many times and never made the connection with Caesarea Philipi - it just seemed an insignificant random location for Jesus to be making such an announcement. In other words, I was missing the context that may have been familiar and significant to those there at the time.

Anyway, thanks for posting more of this series.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts