For a couple years now—ever since I watched the raising-of-Lazarus episode of The Chosen—I have wanted to make a video with clips from different films that depict the raising of Lazarus. Specifically, I have wanted to make a video that focuses on films in which the camera moves or zooms into the darkness of Lazarus’s tomb.
Now that I am nearly finished writing up my notes on that episode of The Chosen, I figured I would finally make the video—and you can watch it above.
The video has clips from four films, and they each put a different spin on the going-into-the-darkness motif:
In Jesus of Nazareth (1977), Jesus kneels before the tomb, says a prayer, and stands up, while John—standing further back—looks at the tomb and quotes Jonah 2:6: “I went down into the countries underneath the earth, to the peoples of the past, but you lifted my life from the pit, Lord, my God.”1 As he quotes the scripture, the camera goes into the tomb. The impression one gets is that John is identifying with Lazarus—and thus, by extension, we are identifying with Lazarus and going down into the pit with him, too. But the scripture quotation also lets us know that Jesus is about to bring Lazarus, and thus by extension us, back out of the pit. And then Jesus raises his hands and tells Lazarus to “come forth”.
In The Last Temptation of Christ (1988), the soundtrack goes quiet—except for buzzing flies and the like—as Jesus kneels at the entrance to the tomb and repeats Lazarus’s name. The camera looks over Jesus’ shoulder and then moves past it into the dark, silent void. When Lazarus responds by reaching out towards Jesus, his body is still semi-decayed, and he briefly pulls Jesus into the tomb with him—but Jesus quickly stands up and lifts him out, and Jesus, despite performing the miracle, seems a bit bewildered by the fact that he actually has the power to do this. There’s a bit of a horror-movie feel to this scene; the camera almost seems to haunt Jesus as it lurks behind his shoulder, and then it goes down into the earth because death has its own ominous pull—its own dangerous gravity, as it were.
In The Visual Bible: The Gospel of John (2003)—a word-for-word adaptation of the fourth gospel—the camera goes into the tomb after Jesus tells Lazarus to “come out”. It is almost as though the camera is sent into the tomb, carrying Jesus’ command to its intended recipient. When Lazarus emerges, we initially see only his shadow against the rocks; we don’t get a good look at him onscreen until after the narrator describes his appearance (i.e. how his body has been wrapped in burial cloths).
In The Chosen (S4E7 ‘The Last Sign’, 2024) the camera does not go into the tomb during the miracle. Instead, it goes into the tomb during a montage that accompanies Mary Magdalene’s monologue at the end of the episode. Mary delivers the monologue in a scene that takes place roughly 30 years after the ministry of Jesus, when she is an old hermit living in a cave in France, and several of the apostles have already been martyred.2 For her, Lazarus’s tomb is a foreshadowing of Jesus’ death, and it is also a reminder of the darkness that she lived with before Jesus cast the demons out of her. So unlike the other films, which go into the tomb in anticipation of Lazarus’s resurrection, The Chosen goes into the tomb while Mary Magdalene is mulling over the fact that death and darkness still exist decades after the Resurrection of Jesus. And that is where the episode ends: After the camera goes into the tomb, there is no movement out of the tomb like there is in the other films; instead, the episode cuts Mary off before she can finish her last sentence, and then it goes straight to the end credits.
So, four films, four very different uses of the going-into-Lazarus’s-tomb visual motif. And The Chosen’s use of that motif is easily the most complex by far.
This verse is Jonah 2:6 in most English Bibles, but the wording in the film comes from the Jerusalem Bible, which follows certain Hebrew manuscripts in calling it Jonah 2:7.
Incidentally, J.R.R. Tolkien wrote the first draft of the Jerusalem Bible’s translation of Jonah. I don’t know how close the final version is to his draft, but when the apostle John speaks in this clip from Jesus of Nazareth, he could be reciting Tolkien!
One more note about the Jonah reference: This verse is part of a prayer that Jonah says when he’s in the belly of the big fish. In the gospels, Jesus compared his own three days in the tomb to the three days Jonah spent in the fish (Matthew 12:38-39; cf Jonah 1:17). But this scene in Jesus of Nazareth encourages us to associate Lazarus with Jonah.
Big James was martyred in the early AD 40s in S2E1; Nathanael was martyred by AD 48 in ‘The Messengers’; and in S4E7, in a scene which seems to take place circa AD 60, Mary Magdalene learns that Little James has recently been martyred, too.

I was horrified at the Scorsese version of this miracle portrayal. Indeed it was obvious that in this depiction of Jesus he had zero confidence in his ability. This would directly stand in the face of Scripture that says that Jesus performed it for the express purpose of showing his power and authority over all things. Also this Jesus timidly calls for Lazarus to come out as if he did not want to be heard in case it didn't work. The fact that Lazarus does not immediately come out also underscores the lack of this Jesus' confidence in his own authority, especially when he seems shocked that Lazarus actually did come out. Also the fact that Lazarus' body was still covered with sores and decay indicates that the healing/restoration was not complete. This portrayal of Jesus is coldly calculated to strip the deity component of Jesus' being and makes him out as a man who may or may not have powers that he certainly does not understand and cannot control.